HRSpotlight-Logo
Menu

Beyond the Google Petition: The Debate Over Job Security Guarantees

How are HR and business leaders responding to the growing calls for greater job security, further propelled by the recent petition from Google employees? 

What are the practical considerations and potential challenges of implementing employment security guarantees across different industries? 

In this post, we tap into the expertise of those on the front lines. 

We’ve gathered insights from leading HR and business executives, asking them to share their opinions on the Google petition and to assess the feasibility of providing employment security guarantees within their specific sectors. 

Their responses offer a grounded perspective on the complexities of this issue and provide valuable guidance for organizations navigating the evolving expectations of the modern workforce.

Read on!

Sania Khan
Founder, Inflection Point Strategy

Sania Khan – Founder

The Google employee petition underscores growing concerns about workforce transitions in the age of AI and automation.

While a job security guarantee may not be entirely feasible in tech, organizations can adopt strategic workforce approaches that enable AI and human talent to evolve together—driving greater long-term ROI than reactive layoffs.

As a labor economist and AI strategist specializing in ethical AI+Human collaboration, I offer insight into AI’s impact on hiring trends, labor markets, and the future of work.

Key Takeaways:

– AI investments must extend beyond cost-cutting. Leaders should ask: Is the workforce upskilled and have the resources to work alongside AI? Productivity gains aren’t automatic.

– Example: A BCGx study on GitHub Copilot found that structured coaching is essential for teams to achieve 2x productivity—AI alone isn’t enough.

– As AI reshapes knowledge work, leaders must redefine Workforce Strategy to ensure AI and human expertise complement rather than replace each other.

– This requires task-level analysis to understand how AI transforms work and how to redeploy talent effectively.

While blanket job security guarantees aren’t realistic, a commitment to workforce resilience and fair transitions is both achievable and necessary.

Companies that focus on long-term agility, upskilling, and AI-human collaboration—not just AI adoption—will emerge as leaders in the future of work.

Samantha Taylor
Business Expert, LLC.org

Samantha Taylor – Business Expert

Job security? It’s a complex problem.

Google employees are seeking an assurance, but in business, there is no such thing as a total assurance.

I’ve dealt with small businesses for over 12 years, assisting them in growing, and one thing is sure, businesses need to stay flexible to succeed.

Lifetime job security guarantee? That can tie a business’s hands.

I work with business owners every day, and they know the key to success is adaptability. Markets move, industries evolve, and companies must change.

If companies can’t pivot, they fail.

That’s why real job security doesn’t lie in a contract, it lies in skills. Workers who constantly learn and grow stay relevant, no matter what happens.

For employers, the most intelligent course of action is to invest in employees, train them, promote them, and give them workplaces where they want to stay.

That’s how you have long-term success, for businesses and workers alike.

I’ve seen it work, time and time again.

Nathan Barz
Founder & CEO, SEO DocVA

Nathan Barz – Founder & CEO

As someone who has navigated corporate restructuring in the financial sector, I see Google’s job security petition as a reflection of broader workforce concerns across industries. 

Over 1,300 employees signed the petition, calling for voluntary buyouts before layoffs, guaranteed severance, and the removal of forced attrition quotas. 

In response, Google introduced a voluntary exit program for its U.S.-based Platforms and Devices team, offering severance packages to those who leave.

From my experience in finance, I’ve seen how major firms handle restructuring, balancing cost-cutting with employee retention strategies. 

Financial institutions have long relied on early retirement incentives and outplacement services to soften the impact of downsizing. 

While absolute job security is unrealistic in today’s dynamic market, companies prioritizing transparency and structured career development foster loyalty and long-term stability. 

Google’s situation highlights the importance of proactive workforce planning, a lesson applicable across industries.

Christopher Pappas
Founder, elearningindustry.com

Christopher Pappas – Founder

Tech employees pushing for job security reveal a deeper concern—workers feel vulnerable in an era of layoffs and AI-driven disruption. 

While companies may not be able to promise lifelong employment, they can provide stability through skill development and career agility.

In L&D and corporate training, we see a major push toward future-proofing talent rather than guaranteeing roles. 

The best companies aren’t offering life contracts—they’re offering skills that keep employees in demand, no matter where they go.

Hayden Cohen
CEO, Hire With Near

Hayden Cohen – CEO

Job security is an important perk to offer your employees.

People want to know that they aren’t going to have their livelihoods threatened by layoffs, and employees with secure jobs are more likely to stick around and go above and beyond for your business.

Offering a blanket guarantee just doesn’t make business sense, though, especially for a massive organization like Google.

Keeping employees who aren’t performing up to standards or who don’t have the skills to handle the work that actually needs doing just doesn’t make business sense.

Samantha Reynolds
Marketing Director, Helpside

Samantha Reynolds – Marketing Director

With the layoff trends of the last few years in the tech industry and the current uncertainty due to AI innovations like DeepSeek, I think it’s understandable that Google’s employees are organizing around their mutual desire for job security.

I work primarily with small and medium-sized companies, and I see my clients creating true job security for their workforce by embracing agility and investing in their employees.

No matter the industry, an ‘employment security guarantee’ is only as good as the people and businesses making the agreement.

However, in a volatile sector like tech, it seems like more of a band-aid than a true solution.

Kevin Franks
President, Comprehensive Marketing

Kevin Franks – President

The tech industry is built on disruption, and any attempt to insulate workers from market shifts is destined to fail.

Just a few years ago, companies were scrambling to hire, offering top dollar even for junior roles. Now, AI and automation are eliminating large swaths of that same workforce. Yet, some workers expect protection.

The reality is simple: every hire must add profit.

Those who fail to adapt to changing industry demands become an expense, not an asset.

No company—no matter how large—can afford to carry non-essential roles indefinitely.

The only true job security lies in continuous evolution and adaptation.

Instead of fighting inevitable change, tech professionals should focus on upskilling, repositioning, and leveraging new technology.

AI isn’t just eliminating jobs—it’s creating new opportunities for those willing to adapt.

In today’s workforce, survival isn’t about tenure; it’s about value.

James McNally
Managing Director, SDVH [Self Drive Vehicle Hire]

James McNally – Managing Director

Job security sounds great on paper, but businesses don’t run on guarantees. Markets shift, costs change, and demand moves.

No company-Google or otherwise-can promise lifetime stability without limiting flexibility.

A smarter approach?

Invest in employee adaptability instead of security guarantees. When people upskill, cross-train, and stay ahead of industry shifts, they create their own job stability.

My company focuses on keeping employees valuable, not just employed. That keeps us lean while making sure our team stays employable-whether with us or somewhere else.

Security doesn’t come from promises. It comes from being too skilled to let go.

Abhishek Shah
Founder, Testlify

Abhishek Shah – Testlify

The job security petition from Google employees highlights a growing concern in the tech industry-workers want more transparency and fairness in layoffs, better severance, and voluntary buyout options.

While an absolute employment security guarantee isn’t always realistic, companies can still foster stability by prioritizing clear communication, fair policies, and career development opportunities.

In my industry, job security depends on adaptability, but building trust through ethical leadership and transparent decision-making can make employees feel more secure, even in uncertain times.

Nik Aggar
Business Development Manager, Outstaff Your Team

Nik Aggar – Business Development Manager

The job security petition from Google employees is definitely a sign of the times. Over 1,400 employees are asking for things like guaranteed severance, voluntary buyouts before layoffs, and fairer performance reviews.

It’s understandable as tech layoffs have been hitting hard recently, even at companies that seem to be doing just fine financially.

As someone who works in staffing, I see both sides of this. On one hand, employees want stability, they want to feel secure in their jobs. On the other hand, businesses, especially in fast-moving industries like tech, need flexibility to adapt to market changes.

Promising job security across the board might sound great in theory, but in practice? It’s tricky. Companies could end up stretched too thin trying to guarantee jobs while staying competitive.

In our world of HR, we focus more on creating opportunities than offering guarantees.

For example, during the pandemic, we saw a big shift toward contract work. Companies needed to stay lean, and workers needed jobs.

It wasn’t perfect as contract work doesn’t come with the same stability or benefits, but it kept people employed and businesses running.

Can companies like Google realistically offer employment guarantees? Maybe to a degree as they’ve got the resources.

But it’s not just about money; it’s also about staying nimble in a competitive market.

A better approach might be improving transparency around layoffs or offering solid severance and reskilling programs.

The HR Spotlight team thanks these industry leaders for offering their expertise and experience and sharing these insights.

Do you wish to contribute to the next HR Spotlight article? Or is there an insight or idea you’d like to share with readers across the globe?

Write to us at connect@HRSpotlight.com, and our team will help you share your insights.

Recent Posts