HRSpotlight-Logo
Menu

Beyond the "No": Communicating with Rejected Candidates

The candidate’s journey doesn’t end with a “yes” or a “no.”

How you handle rejection can have a lasting impact on your company’s reputation and your ability to attract top talent in the future.

Leaders across industries share their surprising insights on the strategic importance of respectful rejection.

Oh, and there’s a counterview too!

Read on!

Steven Mostyn
Chief Human Resource Officer, Management.org

In our organization, we believe in communicating with all applicants, even those who are rejected. We send a personalized email to each rejected candidate, thanking them for their interest and informing them of our decision.

This approach is rooted in our commitment to maintaining a positive employer brand and treating every candidate with respect.

There are clear advantages to this practice. By providing closure, we help applicants move forward in their job search without uncertainty.

Additionally, candidates who receive a thoughtful rejection often view the company more favorably, which can lead to positive word-of-mouth or future applications.

We’ve found that even rejected candidates may reapply for different roles down the line, having had a respectful and transparent experience.

Skipping this step could damage our employer brand and leave potential future talent with a negative impression.

Marin Cristian-Ovidiu
CEO, Online Games

As the CEO of Online Games, I ensure that we always inform candidates when their job application is rejected.

Although we’re a small team and handle hiring ourselves, we believe in maintaining professionalism and treating applicants with respect. Communicating rejections not only provides closure but also leaves a positive impression of our company, which is crucial in the competitive gaming industry.

This practice has resulted in some candidates expressing appreciation for our transparency, and they’ve even recommended our games or applied for other positions later.

Ignoring applicants, on the other hand, would harm our brand’s reputation and diminish our ability to attract talent in the future.

Ryan Farley
CEO of LawnStarter

I do tend to see a quick follow up informing an applicant of a rejection as the courteous thing to do, so I’ve always made this policy.

However, I tend to make more of a point if I’m rejecting someone after a first interview. It’s less of a priority for people who have only applied, since I think it’s pretty common for no response to be taken as a rejection in those cases.

But, if someone’s put in the time and effort to prepare for an interview, I do think it’s kind and respectful to let them know if they’re no longer being considered.

Andre Kazimierski
CEO, Improovy

Personally I don’t see it being very necessary to send a rejection for every application I put on the “no” pile. For any given position I can receive tens of applications, and I’ll pick just a couple or a few applicants to actually bring in for an interview.

Of course I’ll always send a rejection after an interview, but for someone who’s just turned in an application and resume, I’m not sure it’s necessary.

Shenella Karunaratne
Director of Operations, Online MFT Programs

I do think it’s nice to communicate rejections to applicants.

From what I have found, it can improve the overall impression of your company if you have the respect for someone’s time to send even a simple form rejection.

Otherwise, candidates can experience some stress from waiting to hear, especially if it’s a position they’re excited about.

David Weisselberger
Founding Partner, Erase The Case

We prioritize empathy and respect in our employment process, particularly when dealing with rejected job applications.

Our HR team takes a personalized approach, ensuring that each applicant receives prompt and constructive feedback. We feel that skipping this stage would damage the trust and dignity of people who spent time and effort applying.

Instead, our experienced HR representatives provide thoughtful rejection emails or phone conversations that include detailed reasons for the choice as well as helpful ideas for future growth.

This approach reflects our respect for their interest and commitment to assisting individuals in overcoming adversities, which is a core value mirrored in our objective to clear criminal records.

This ensures a great applicant experience and helps us keep our reputation as sensitive advocates.

Adam Chahl
Founder, Vancouver Home Search

At Vancouver Home Search, we believe in maintaining transparency and respect throughout the hiring process. For me, it’s important to treat applicants the way we’d want to be treated.

So, yes, our HR team does inform rejected applicants. While it’s not always easy to send rejection emails, we do it because it’s a reflection of our company’s values—clear communication and professionalism.

In my experience, informing candidates of a decision builds goodwill and leaves the door open for future opportunities. It also strengthens our brand by showing respect for the time applicants invested.

Sure, it takes some effort, but it’s well worth it. Skipping this step just isn’t in line with how I believe businesses should operate, every interaction counts.

Andrei Kurtuy
CCO & Co-Founder, Novorésumé

At Novorésumé, we prioritize informing all rejected applicants, and here’s why: we see it as an opportunity to build long-term relationships.

Sending a thoughtful rejection email is not just about good manners—it’s a strategic investment in our employer brand. It shows respect for the candidate’s time and effort, which fosters goodwill and leaves the door open for future opportunities.

In a competitive talent market, how you handle rejection can be the difference between someone leaving with a positive view of your company or feeling disregarded.

Many of our applicants have returned to apply for different roles because they appreciate the transparent and respectful rejection process. Some have even referred others to us, boosting our talent pipeline.

Communicating rejections humanizes the hiring process, reminding candidates that, while they weren’t the right fit this time, their efforts are recognized and valued.

Counterview

Carla Niña Pornelos
General Manager, Wardnasse

We believe transparency is key to building a strong reputation. Here’s the truth: we don’t inform rejected applicants.

Why? We don’t believe in softening the truth. If someone doesn’t hear back from us— it means they didn’t make it. In the real world, no one hands out rejection notices, and we want people to be ready for that. It’s a tough reality— but one we think is needed in today’s fast-paced world.

Letting someone know they’ve been turned down just makes them wait for the next chance instead of pushing themselves to get better.

At Wardnasse, we expect applicants to seek feedback and grow, not wait for someone to spell it out. This approach has made us stronger—and we think it’s time more companies followed suit.

The HR Spotlight team thanks these industry leaders for offering their expertise and experience and sharing their insights.

Do you wish to contribute to the next HR Spotlight article? Or is there an insight or idea you’d like to share with readers across the globe?

Write to us at connect@HRSpotlight.com, and our team will help you share your insights.

Recent Posts