6 Reasons Why Employers Scan a Candidate’s Online Behavior

May 5, 2023

Our behavior on social media has a real impact on our lives, personal as well as professional. And if you don’t believe this to be true, you can ask anyone who has been fired over their comments on their social media channel to confirm just how true this is.

The opposite is equally true too. There are so many cases where someone’s positive social media behavior has been rewarded at the workplace. Ask any of those large-hearted waitresses who have received wholehearted support from the brands they work for when they’ve gone the extra mile to treat their customers well.

The examples are many, and they play out either way too, but there’s really no denying that your behavior online certainly has an impact on your professional life too. So is this scanning of your online persona limited to your role as an employee? Or does it play out behind the scenes even when you’re seeking employment?

Ask any HR or hiring manager and they’ll tell you that reviewing your online behavior is indeed part of the process. But what do they expect to verify by doing this? What are the reasons that drive them to go through your online persona and see what you’re made of beyond the resume you’ve presented?

From checking for company fit to learning private integrity, here are six answers to the question, “Most employers now scan the online/profile behavior of potential candidates. What are your reasons for this practice?”

Determines Company Fit
Shows the Real Candidate
Filters Out Troublemakers
Controls Your Online Reputation
Exposes Red Flags
Uncovers the Candidate’s Private Integrity

Determines Company Fit

Scanning online behavior can be a great way to see if a candidate is a good fit for the company culture. I’m not talking about seeing their interests or following other companies merely, but rather about how they use their online platform.

Are they posting about going to the gym and eating well, or are they complaining about work or the people they work with? Online profiles are windows into a person’s life, and employers are using them to determine if candidates are the right fit for their company.

Matthew Ramirez, CEO, Rephrasely

Shows the Real Candidate

Employers want to get a fuller idea of what the person they’re hiring is like. Social media can allow them to understand what a person’s behavior represents when they aren’t acting on a script. It provides a more natural view of a candidate than they might see during an interview.

If understanding a candidate before hiring saves a company from having to deal with behavior troubles or legal liabilities of any sort, then it’s already worth the effort.

Max Schwartzapfel
CMO, Schwartzapfel Lawyers

If understanding a candidate before hiring saves a company from having to deal with behavior troubles or legal liabilities of any sort, then it’s already worth the effort. It will always be better for a company to reject an unsuitable candidate than it will be to fix any issue caused by them in hindsight.

Max Schwartzapfel, CMO, Schwartzapfel Lawyers

Filters Out Troublemakers

I’ve learned the hard way how important it is to conduct candidate background checks, especially their social media profiles.

Five years ago, I hired an apparently perfect candidate for a role, only to have the HR department bombarded with complaints about inappropriate remarks and insensitive behavior towards other employees. Later, I discovered this was the norm for him; his Facebook profile was full of problematic status updates, racist quotes, and shockingly sexist remarks.

With challenging times ahead for businesses, I think it’s better to deep-dive into whatever candidate information is available instead of risking hiring them, only to terminate them and rehire someone else in a month.

Anjela Mangrum
President, Mangrum Career Solutions

Sometimes, online profiles can also provide clues about the legitimacy of applications that seem too good to be true. With challenging times ahead for businesses, I think it’s better to deep-dive into whatever candidate information is available instead of risking hiring them, only to terminate them and rehire someone else in a month. As it is, with the current challenges of running a business, office drama is the last thing we need!

Anjela Mangrum, President, Mangrum Career Solutions

Controls Your Online Reputation

The things that an employee posts or does online don’t just impact their individual reputation; they can also influence how people view or think about your company, even when someone is posting on their personal social media.

Many customers today want to do business with companies that share their values, and job seekers feel the same way about employers. If you hire someone who’s an online bully or regularly posts offensive content, this could lead to people associating these behaviors with your company, and your online reputation as a business can suffer.

If you hire someone who’s an online bully or regularly posts offensive content, this could lead to people associating these behaviors with your company, and your online reputation as a business can suffer.

Archie Payne
CEO, CalTek Staffing

This is aside from the potential impact on your team, culture, and morale from hiring someone who’s hostile, prejudiced, or otherwise toxic, although that’s something else that’s important to consider. Scanning the profiles and posting behavior of candidates before they get through the interview process is an easy way to check for red flags and avoid hiring someone who will cause you these kinds of headaches.

Archie Payne, CEO, CalTek Staffing

Exposes Red Flags

People always warned us in college that employers would search through our social media. It’s true because, as I am in charge of gathering candidates for new openings, the first thing I do when someone applies is look over their social media profiles. We do this to see if they will be a good fit with our company culture.

Obviously, you want employees who will show up on time and get along with others. When I see people who have their profile photos as themselves flipping off the camera and smoking drugs, those are red flags that they probably wouldn’t do well in our culture. With social media, you are supposed to put your best foot forward or show the best side of yourself. Make sure it truly is the best side you are showing others.

Seth Newman, Director, Sporting Smiles

Uncovers the Candidate’s Private Integrity

Social identity online is vital for employers to determine the integrity of potential candidates. Candidates with a dirty online identity can damage the reputation of the brand and link it with associated behaviors, such as racism or sexism.

Online scanning can validate the information that potential candidates provide and help gauge the intangible aspects of trust and integrity. It is also vital for security to avoid hiring candidates involved in illegal activities such as money laundering and cybercrime. It is also a way to eliminate unconscious bias through objective scanning of potential candidates.

Yongming Song, CEO, Live Poll For Slides

Scanning a Candidate’s Online Behavior Does Make a Lot of Sense!

Pick up any of these points shared by workplace leaders and you’ll know there are plenty of valid reasons to review a candidate’s online behavior and determine if they’d be a good fit or not. So the next time you post something or leave a comment without thinking twice, remember that your potential employers will get to it, review it, and probably use it as enough reason to reject you.

Do you have a valid pointer to add to this list? Or is there another topic you’d like to start a conversation around on the HR Spotlight platform?

Write to us at connect@HRSpotlight.com, and our team will help you share your insights.